How do you want others to see you? A quick answer might be, "I want them to see me positively—to value, admire, or even idealise me." While this desire for a positive perception is common, research in social and personality psychology suggests a surprising twist. According to William Swann's self-verification theory (1981), what we truly seek is for others to see us exactly as we see ourselves—whether that view is positive or negative.
The surprising insight of self-verification: Studies reveal that individuals with a negative self-image often prefer that others share this same perception. Why? Because a mismatch between our self-image and how others see us can create feelings of being misunderstood, leading to discomfort and conflict in social interactions. On the other hand, when others confirm our self-view, we feel psychologically coherent and socially stable, even if that self-view isn’t positive.
Why do we seek alignment?: The desire for alignment between our self-image and others’ perceptions stems from our need for stability and understanding. When others validate our self-view:
Social interactions become smoother: We feel less conflicted and more understood.
We build a sense of coherence: It reinforces our understanding of ourselves and the world around us.
This preference for alignment can influence various aspects of life, from choosing social groups to navigating personal and professional relationships.
When positive feedback feels misaligned: What happens when someone offers us positive feedback that doesn’t match our self-image? According to Swann, this can create inner conflict. For example, someone with low self-esteem may feel uncomfortable or even resistant to positive reinforcement because it clashes with their negative self-view. In such cases, the individual might gravitate toward feedback or relationships that validate their existing self-perception, even if it’s negative.
Practical implications of self-verification theory: Self-verification theory has practical applications in various contexts, including relationships and workplaces:
In relationships: Research shows that in long-term, stable relationships, individuals value partners who perceive them as they perceive themselves. This mutual understanding fosters trust and reduces conflict. However, in short-term interactions, such as casual dating, individuals may prioritize positive feedback over alignment.
In the workplace: Employees with low self-esteem often prefer managers or colleagues who view them in alignment with their self-perception. This preference can impact team dynamics and workplace communication.
Self-verification vs. self-enhancement: While self-verification focuses on seeking consistency between self-perception and others’ views, self-enhancement involves seeking positive feedback to boost self-esteem. These two drives can sometimes conflict, creating dilemmas in how we process and respond to feedback from others.
Why this matters for personal growth: Understanding self-verification theory can help us become more mindful of how our self-perception shapes our relationships and decisions. If we’re aware of a tendency to seek validation for a negative self-image, we can take steps to challenge and reshape that image. Developing a more positive and empowered self-view allows us to align our interactions with the person we aspire to be.
Aligning your self-image with your aspirations: As a coach deeply invested in personal growth and self-awareness—and currently pursuing a degree in psychology—I help individuals uncover and transform the beliefs that shape their self-image. Together, we can work on creating a self-view that aligns with the person you want to become and the life you dream of living.
Comments